Jimmy Fallon paid tribute to Prince on The Tonight Show by sharing a ridiculous — but apparently true — story about being beaten at ping-pong by the late, great artist.

Tales of Prince’s surprising athletic prowess are everywhere, from the time he destroyed Charlie Murphy at basketball to the time he beat New Girl‘s Jessica Day at ping pong.

Now Jimmy Fallon has added to the legend with this tale, in which Prince demands that the talk show host comes to Susan Sarandon’s New York ping pong club, Spin, to play against him, even though Fallon had a newborn baby waiting for him at home.

We don’t want to spoil the details, because it’s a great story with a great punchline, but suffice to say it’s full of classic Prince quirkiness. Watch the clip above!

You might also like…
See Prince on the big screen in Brisbane
Watch Prince upstage Michael Jackson and James Brown